SGA - The Tower

[amalthia]

Loved this episode...more behind the cut This is so odd, this is the first episode I really felt like squeeing to. I had so many OMG moments. :) it was wonderful, it was like fan fiction actually but in a good way.

Um favorite moments....I think when the blonde drops her clothes and John's all over her until he hears ruler....Rodney in the city trying to save the day. I even liked the guards with the whips and the cowering townspeople! Okay not sure what that says about me, but I kept thinking this episode has so many elements of various SGA fan fics I've read.

Um it was a lot of fun to watch. Last week I really loved Grace Under Pressure however except for the Sea MONSTER I didn't really feel any squeeing. this one was a lot of fun for some reason. I just want to know what the writers were smoking when they wrote it. Or what romance novels they've been reading.

Comments

[ladyamarra.livejournal.com]

Mckay was just droolworthy *snicker* with his trustworthy guide and all, just really good. But, well, you are so right, I had to think of a Stargate Atlantis/Lord of the rings crossover I read back in the day and, well, I think the guys who wrote this really read the same story, because it was so obviously done like some of the Fanfictions on crack out there.

You are right with what you say about John, it's just adorable, but really, really too much into his role as Pegasus version of Captain Kirk. Lt. Colonel Kirk i mean. Which annoyed me a bit, because they really don't need to play with that cliche so much, or at least give the others some action too. Anyway, Carson was adorable "I should really stop doing housecalls" or something smoothed out the whole Shakespearian (is that right? is that even a word?) crap, anyway, and simply from the position of the art student; decorating Atlantis like a french whorehouse out of the 16century really, really was no whise thing to do. *jeez*

Do I rant too much? Well, yes I do. But at least we have Mckay and Ronon to smooth other things.

[amalthia]

You don't rant that much. :) Yeah I loved the crappy costumes and the bad acting. Which I know is a kind of odd thing to like but I don't think the episode would have worked otherwise. OH and Rodney's guide. I loved that guy. His questions and comments were just so funny, or maybe it was Rodney's reaction.

I think it'll be nice if we see an episode from Teyla's pov and have all the hot alien guys hit on her or something. or even Ronon. or Rodney...it does seem rather unfair that all the hot women in the galaxy drool over Sheppard.

I also loved Carson in this episode. :)